nanog mailing list archives
Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs
From: Mehmet Akcin <mehmet () akcin net>
Date: Sun, 4 Aug 2019 13:12:13 -0700
Keith, thank you for your response, I think this is slightly becoming offtopic, I will take this offlist with you but in short, that's not how GeoServer works (or mainly GIS when displaying things publicly) for something to be displayed to you, it needs to make it available, and if it's available it can be downloaded with codes/programs that allow you to, we are preventing this by forcing users to log in that way someone can't simply launch a script and get all of the data available in our platform (or if they do, we would notice, know who and stop it via rate-limits). I am neither a security nor GIS expert, I am relying on what I was told/advised. On Sun, Aug 4, 2019 at 1:06 PM Keith Medcalf <kmedcalf () dessus com> wrote:
On Sunday, 4 August, 2019 12:20, Mehmet Akcin <mehmet () akcin net> wrote:I understand and share your frustration about forcing account registration. We had no other way but to implement this as constantly we had sources trying to download our data by examining our code. By having access controls we were able to stop that. My team had recommended user data controls after reviewing Geoserver, mapbox requirements, if you know any other way please feel free to recommend.You permit anyone to view the code running on your web server? Do you permit them to modify it too? Nevertheless, just deny code viewing permission on your web server and only serve output of executing that code. Quite simple. And no one can steal your code (unless you let them into the room containing the web server). -- The fact that there's a Highway to Hell but only a Stairway to Heaven says a lot about anticipated traffic volume.
Current thread:
- Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Ross Tajvar (Aug 03)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Mike Hammett (Aug 03)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Ross Tajvar (Aug 03)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Brian Henson (Aug 03)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Ross Tajvar (Aug 03)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Mark Tinka (Aug 03)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Mehmet Akcin (Aug 03)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Fred Baker (Aug 04)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Mehmet Akcin (Aug 04)
- RE: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Keith Medcalf (Aug 04)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Mehmet Akcin (Aug 04)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Ross Tajvar (Aug 03)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Tony Finch (Aug 05)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Mehmet Akcin (Aug 05)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Mike Hammett (Aug 03)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Nikos Leontsinis (Aug 05)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Eric Kuhnke (Aug 03)
- Re: Best ways to ensure redundancy with no terrestrial ISPs Ross Tajvar (Aug 05)