nanog mailing list archives

Re: Interesting BFD discussion on reddit


From: Sudeep Khuraijam <skhuraijam () liveops com>
Date: Fri, 20 Feb 2015 14:17:25 -0800




On (2015-02-17 06:11 +0530), Glen Kent wrote:

I think the hardware used was Broadcom. They have a few chipsets which
do
MD5 and (possibly) SHA in hardware for BFD -- which i have been told is
pretty much useless when you start scaling.

While I donĀ¹t fully understand the context of this particular test and the
scaling limitation, there are merchant silicon, NPUs and even CPUs that do
support MD5 and SHA
at transport line rate requirements.  BFD requirements are just a fraction
of these capabilities.

The option to negotiate capabilities should be available independent of
scaling/cost/inefficiencies at present time.  It is a matter of
implementation/product design choice.

Sudeep Khuraijam


Current thread: