nanog mailing list archives
Re: ICMP Redirect on Resolvers
From: Owen DeLong <owen () delong com>
Date: Sun, 7 Apr 2013 12:25:30 -0700
On Apr 6, 2013, at 16:03 , Valdis.Kletnieks () vt edu wrote:
On Sat, 06 Apr 2013 10:38:06 -0400, shawn wilson said:What would break if u dropped all ICMP packets with redirects on public facing boxes?Presumably nothing, as long as you guaranteed that your IP address, netmask, and routes actually match the reality of your network configuration. In that case, you shouldn't see any valid ICMP redirects. They're there mostly so things kind-of-sort-of work even if you botch it (so for instance, even if you whiff your default route accidentally, you can still ssh in from Tokyo and fix it).
Not entirely true. They also cover the case where there are two (or more) routers on the network and you don't want to have to configure more specific routes on all your workstations. For example, network B has routers [A] and [C]. Router [A] leads to the internet. Router [C] leads to networks R, S, T, and U. Hosts on network B can be configured with default->[A] and as long as [A] and [C] have proper routing information via IGP, BGP, and/or static routing including all of the more specifics, then [A] can send back redirects to hosts on network B when they try to reach networks {R,S,T,U}. If you block ICMP redirects, then you won't break anything, but you will increase the traffic load on network B and router [A] as it will hairpin all of the traffic from those hosts to {R,S,T,U}. Owen
Current thread:
- ICMP Redirect on Resolvers Shahab Vahabzadeh (Apr 05)
- Re: ICMP Redirect on Resolvers Tony Finch (Apr 05)
- RE: ICMP Redirect on Resolvers Keith Medcalf (Apr 05)
- Re: ICMP Redirect on Resolvers Jimmy Hess (Apr 06)
- Re: ICMP Redirect on Resolvers shawn wilson (Apr 06)
- Re: ICMP Redirect on Resolvers Valdis . Kletnieks (Apr 06)
- Re: ICMP Redirect on Resolvers Jimmy Hess (Apr 06)
- Re: ICMP Redirect on Resolvers Owen DeLong (Apr 07)
- Re: ICMP Redirect on Resolvers Valdis . Kletnieks (Apr 07)
- Re: ICMP Redirect on Resolvers Owen DeLong (Apr 07)
- Re: ICMP Redirect on Resolvers Jimmy Hess (Apr 06)