nanog mailing list archives
RE: Firewall Appliance Suggestions
From: "Blake T. Pfankuch" <blake () pfankuch me>
Date: Fri, 1 Jul 2011 04:35:22 +0000
Normally I would agree with you as far as separate instances, however this will be in a situation where we pay ridiculous amounts for cpu and memory, so a single instance is what we are shooting for (remember those ridiculous requirements). I am planning to do some further testing with vyatta and pfsense. Thanks you all for the on list and off list responses! -----Original Message----- From: Sargun Dhillon [mailto:sargun () sargun me] Sent: Thursday, June 30, 2011 9:56 PM To: George Bonser Cc: Blake T. Pfankuch; NANOG (nanog () nanog org) Subject: Re: Firewall Appliance Suggestions ----- Original Message -----
From: "George Bonser" <gbonser () seven com> To: "Blake T. Pfankuch" <blake () pfankuch me>, "NANOG (nanog () nanog org)" <nanog () nanog org> Sent: Thursday, June 30, 2011 11:30:53 AM Subject: RE: Firewall Appliance SuggestionsWilling to pay for something if need be, but looking for something that can easily handly 50-100mbit of throughput. Any Ideas? Thanks! Blake PfankuchI might also look at Vyatta. They have appliances or you can run the software on your own hardware.
I would not go with Vyatta if you're doing anything complex. The number of random bugs I've hit with their software are numerous. In the right hands, it's a powerful tool. And it seems to fit your solution really well. If I were in your shoes, I would install two instances that would handle the "edge" of the cluster, and then an instance per customer (lightweight, they sell a VMWare image). Then use dynamic routing to direct traffic to the customer (assign each customer their own ASN, and peer with their instance). So, worse case scenario, the NOC monkey only breaks one customer's gear. -- Sargun Dhillon VoIP (US): +1-925-235-1105
Current thread:
- Firewall Appliance Suggestions Blake T. Pfankuch (Jun 30)
- Re: Firewall Appliance Suggestions -Hammer- (Jun 30)
- RE: Firewall Appliance Suggestions Blake T. Pfankuch (Jun 30)
- Re: Firewall Appliance Suggestions -Hammer- (Jun 30)
- RE: Firewall Appliance Suggestions Leigh Porter (Jun 30)
- RE: Firewall Appliance Suggestions Blake T. Pfankuch (Jun 30)
- Re: Firewall Appliance Suggestions Suresh Rajagopalan (Jun 30)
- RE: Firewall Appliance Suggestions George Bonser (Jun 30)
- Message not available
- RE: Firewall Appliance Suggestions Blake T. Pfankuch (Jun 30)
- Message not available
- Re: Firewall Appliance Suggestions -Hammer- (Jun 30)
- Re: Firewall Appliance Suggestions Brent Jones (Jun 30)
- Re: Firewall Appliance Suggestions Chris Lowe (Jun 30)
- Re: Firewall Appliance Suggestions Rhys Rhaven (Jun 30)