nanog mailing list archives
RE: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block
From: "Tony Hain" <alh-ietf () tndh net>
Date: Wed, 20 Oct 2010 17:28:12 -0700
John Curran wrote:
On Oct 20, 2010, at 11:35 AM, Christopher Morrow wrote:yes, sorry.. since this was returned to ARIN, I assumed the ARIN region drain rate.Ah, good point. It may end up in the global pool, so comparison to either drain rate is quite reasonable.
For what it's worth, at this point it really doesn't matter much if 45/8 stays at ARIN or goes back to IANA. RIPE is due for a pair around 12/15 -->> IANA @ 10 APnic burned through the last 2 in 67 days, so given end of year slowing they should be back for another pair around 1/2/11. -->> IANA @ 8 If 45/8 goes back to IANA, ARIN is due to get a pair around 2/1. -->> IANA @ 6 + 45/8 APnic comes back for the last one + 45/8 around 3/1 -->> IANA @ 5 triggers end of pool. If ARIN keeps 45/8, the only difference would be they would probably not qualify for the estimated 2/1/11 allocation, so that event would be delayed and when 45/8 was used up so they would qualify, there would only be 1 left because APnic would have gotten their pair around 3/1 first. Any way you cut it, around 3/1/11 APnic/ARIN/RIPE will each be holding around 4 /8's + their remaining share of 'Various Registries' (ARIN's last one could sit at IANA for an additional couple of weeks, but they would still be next in line unless they take too long). The wild card to the above scenario is Afrinic. They are close enough for an unusual event to qualify them for another /8 from IANA within this timeframe. If that happens, the disposition of 45/8 could impact how many APnic is holding around 3/1/11. Given that APnic is burning through a /8 on an accelerating pace currently at 33 days, +/- one will impact how soon the address market takes off. If Afrinic gets one and 45/8 stays at ARIN, APnic will pick up the last pair at IANA around 3/1 and be completely out within 6 months. If 45/8 goes back, ARIN picks up 2 in early Feb, so with Afrinic getting one there would only be one left for APnic. Tony
Current thread:
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block, (continued)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block Christopher Morrow (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block John Curran (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block Justin M. Streiner (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block John Curran (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block Jeroen van Aart (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block Majdi S. Abbas (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block Christopher Morrow (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block John Curran (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block Christopher Morrow (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block John Curran (Oct 20)
- RE: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block Tony Hain (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block Joe Maimon (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block Ernie Rubi (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block John Curran (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block John Curran (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block Jack Bates (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block Joel Esler (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block David Conrad (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block Joel Esler (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block Randy Carpenter (Oct 20)
- Re: ARIN recognizes Interop for return of more than 99% of 45/8 address block Franck Martin (Oct 20)