nanog mailing list archives

Re: Who controlls the Internet?


From: David Conrad <drc () virtualized org>
Date: Sun, 25 Jul 2010 21:17:17 +0200

On Jul 25, 2010, at 8:05 PM, Tarig Yassin wrote:
probabaly every web server in USA e.g. Google, Verisign and sourceforge.

ALL companies that operate in the US are bound by law to abide by restrictions that are defined at 
http://www.ustreas.gov/offices/enforcement/ofac/ and elsewhere.  Failure to abide by those laws can result in criminal 
sanctions (that is, being thrown in jail for years).  

However, the US is not the only country that restricts who does business with whom.  I suspect you'll find pretty much 
every country in the world has a similar list in one form or another.  In many cases, and depending on context, 
companies can obtain licenses that permit the provision of content and services to countries and people that are under 
sanction, but those companies have to do the work and I suspect most find it isn't worth the effort.

In addition, Intellectual Property owners may decide that they want to deny access to content for arbitrary reasons.  
Examples of this outside of the Internet are region encoded DVDs.  These restrictions are determined by business 
models. 

The issue isn't that the US has these restrictions, rather it is that there is a lot of useful content that is 
generated in and/or distributed from the US.  One could argue that this encourages creation of and distribution 
channels for useful content outside the US...

What if a large orginization which has an infrstructure in many countires, in which regulations the will comply, in 
terms to ban other countries accessing to thier Internet resources.

As has been pointed out, the Internet is a set of interconnected public and private networks. Each of those networks 
has their own rules about who they'll grant access and what resources they'll make available.  

Regards,
-drc



Current thread: