nanog mailing list archives
Re: Did your BGP crash today?
From: Jared Mauch <jared () puck nether net>
Date: Fri, 27 Aug 2010 15:22:52 -0400
On Aug 27, 2010, at 3:17 PM, Jeroen Massar wrote:
On 2010-08-27 21:13, Richard A Steenbergen wrote:On Fri, Aug 27, 2010 at 01:29:15PM -0400, Jared Mauch wrote:Unknown BGP attribute 99 (flags: 240) Unknown BGP attribute 99 (flags: 240) Unknown BGP attribute 99 (flags: 240) Unknown BGP attribute 99 (flags: 240) Unknown BGP attribute 99 (flags: 240)Just out of curiosity, at what point will we as operators rise up against the ivory tower protocol designers at the IETF and demand that they add a mechanism to not bring down the entire BGP session because of a single malformed attribute? Did I miss the memo about the meeting? I'll bring the punch and pie.Complain to your vendor, especially C & J are having good enough influence on the IETF to make such a change possible. I can agree with tearing the session down when one encounters an improperly formatted message, but an unknown attribute, while the rest of the format of message is fine, is a silly thing to hang up on indeed.
When you are processing something, it's sometimes hard to tell if something just was mis-parsed (as I think the case is here with the "missing-2-bytes") vs just getting garbage. Perhaps there should be some way to "re-sync" when you are having this problem, or a parallel "keepalive" path similar to MACA/MCAS/MIDCAS/TCAS between the devices to talk when something bad is happening. - Jared
Current thread:
- Did your BGP crash today? Kasper Adel (Aug 27)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? Jared Mauch (Aug 27)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? Richard A Steenbergen (Aug 27)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? Jeroen Massar (Aug 27)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? Jared Mauch (Aug 27)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? Dave Israel (Aug 27)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? Mike Gatti (Aug 27)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? Christopher Morrow (Aug 27)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? bmanning (Aug 27)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? Warren Kumari (Aug 27)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? Thomas Mangin (Aug 28)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? Randy Bush (Aug 28)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? Thomas Mangin (Aug 28)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? Randy Bush (Aug 28)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? Saku Ytti (Aug 28)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? Richard A Steenbergen (Aug 27)
- Re: Did your BGP crash today? Jared Mauch (Aug 27)