nanog mailing list archives
Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster
From: Christopher Morrow <morrowc.lists () gmail com>
Date: Mon, 9 Aug 2010 23:29:53 -0400
On Mon, Aug 9, 2010 at 3:18 PM, Zaid Ali <zaid () zaidali com> wrote:
The devil is always in the details. The Network management piece is quite glossed over and gives a different perception in the summary. You can't perform the proposed network management piece without deep packet inspection which violates every users privacy.
how is that though? you COULD do something odd like say: "Anything to zaid-ali's netblocks is preferred in queues over things to jolymacfie's netblocks. that wouldn't require any DPI at all, just a traffic classification engine on/near the endpoint, say like on the DocSIS modem, or on the handset itself... many handsets are unix-ish things with some ability to do 'firewall' things, certainly they could mark packets outbound, certainly at peering points a network could classify in simple ways and mark packets properly there as well. nothing required DPI, unless you want to delve into: "That is not ssh on port 22" port 443 is the new port 80! woot! -chris
Current thread:
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster, (continued)
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster Harry Hoffman (Aug 10)
- RE: Google wants your Internet to be faster Justin Horstman (Aug 10)
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster Kevin Oberman (Aug 10)
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster Jeroen van Aart (Aug 10)
- RE: Google wants your Internet to be faster Joseph Jackson (Aug 10)
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster Kevin Oberman (Aug 10)
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster Valdis . Kletnieks (Aug 10)
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster Joly MacFie (Aug 10)
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster Kevin Oberman (Aug 10)
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster Matthew Palmer (Aug 09)
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster Christopher Morrow (Aug 09)
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster Sean Donelan (Aug 10)
- RE: Google wants your Internet to be faster Nathan Eisenberg (Aug 10)
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster Kenny Sallee (Aug 10)
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster Mike Sabbota (Aug 10)
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster Christopher Morrow (Aug 10)
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster Kenny Sallee (Aug 10)
- RE: Google wants your Internet to be faster Nathan Eisenberg (Aug 10)
- Re: Google wants your Internet to be faster Kenny Sallee (Aug 10)