nanog mailing list archives
Re: [admin] Using the NANOG list as a paging mechanism
From: "Perry E. Metzger" <perry () piermont com>
Date: Sun, 06 Jan 2008 17:01:18 -0500
"Martin Hannigan" <hannigan () gmail com> writes:
We'd like to politely note that paging each other on the list without content or context is generally off-topic.
I understand the motivation, but I think the "paging" messages should be allowed. I've done it myself, in desperation after exhausting all other ways to find a needed contact. I don't think that the current rate of "desperately searching for contact at provider X" is impossibly high, and often this is the only way to find a contact you really, really need. Certainly people should be encouraged to try all other possibilities first, but what if you already have?
These messages are perceived by many as fragments that are not useful to the wider community.
Compared to most of the other traffic here, they're actually useful. The endless debates haven't helped me much over the years, but the couple of times I've really, really needed to find an appropriate contact and had no luck any other way, this list has come through for me.
If you could provide some level of detail as to why you are using the list to reach someone, it would be much appreciated.
In my own instances, posting private security related information to the internet seemed like a bad idea, so I must politely refuse. -- Perry E. Metzger perry () piermont com
Current thread:
- [admin] Using the NANOG list as a paging mechanism Martin Hannigan (Jan 04)
- Re: [admin] Using the NANOG list as a paging mechanism Patrick Clochesy (Jan 04)
- Re: [admin] Using the NANOG list as a paging mechanism Bill Nash (Jan 04)
- Re: [admin] Using the NANOG list as a paging mechanism Robert E. Seastrom (Jan 05)
- Re: [admin] Using the NANOG list as a paging mechanism C. Jon Larsen (Jan 05)
- Re: [admin] Using the NANOG list as a paging mechanism Perry E. Metzger (Jan 06)
- Re: [admin] Using the NANOG list as a paging mechanism Bill Stewart (Jan 08)
- Re: [admin] Using the NANOG list as a paging mechanism Deepak Jain (Jan 08)
- Re: [admin] Using the NANOG list as a paging mechanism Martin Hannigan (Jan 08)
- Re: [admin] Using the NANOG list as a paging mechanism Bill Stewart (Jan 08)
- Re: [admin] Using the NANOG list as a paging mechanism Patrick Clochesy (Jan 04)