nanog mailing list archives
Re: Yahoo outage summary
From: Randy Bush <randy () psg com>
Date: Tue, 10 Jul 2007 00:31:01 +0800
Tony Tauber wrote:
On Mon, Jul 09, 2007 at 02:31:10PM +0800, Randy Bush wrote:following existing BCPs with currently-deployed techniques/functionality/features would have prevented the issue described in the post.knowing that level(3) is one of the most serious deployments of irr-based route filters and other prudent practices, perhaps we should wait for a post mortem from level(3) before jumping to conclusions?There's no magic bullet in updating BGP if a fundamental, verifiable data model is not accepted and agreed upon.
the space of routing data validation is large, we can explore it at our leisure, and we have been for some years. but my point was that it is silly to indulge in conjecturbation on the cause of the recent event and excoriate l(3), hanaro, or john curran's grandmother until we have heard from the folk who have actual data. randy
Current thread:
- Re: Yahoo outage summary, (continued)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Patrick W. Gilmore (Jul 09)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Florian Weimer (Jul 09)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Lixia Zhang (Jul 08)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Cat Okita (Jul 08)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Andy Dills (Jul 08)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Sam Stickland (Jul 10)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Roland Dobbins (Jul 08)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Randy Bush (Jul 08)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Roland Dobbins (Jul 08)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Tony Tauber (Jul 09)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Randy Bush (Jul 09)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Sean Donelan (Jul 09)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Douglas Otis (Jul 09)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Steven M. Bellovin (Jul 08)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Sean Donelan (Jul 08)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Joe Abley (Jul 09)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Jared Mauch (Jul 09)
- Re: Yahoo outage summary Tony Tauber (Jul 09)