nanog mailing list archives
Re: a radical proposal (Re: protocols that don't meet the need...)
From: Joe Abley <jabley () isc org>
Date: Fri, 17 Feb 2006 00:13:48 -0500
On 16-Feb-2006, at 13:32, Edward B. DREGER wrote:
JA> I get the feeling that there's a lot of solutions-designing going on in thisJA> thread without the benefit of prior problem-stating. Problem: Consumers want to multihome.
That sentence needs profound expansion before it's going to be reasonable to assess any proposed solution.
(Why do they want to multi-home? What do they hope to achieve? Redundancy? Load sharing? What trade-offs are reasonable, e.g. with respect to the stability of individual sessions across re-homing events? In a transaction carried between two hosts, do clients and servers have different requirements?)
We tried to catch a reasonable number of motivations in RFC 3582, but I bet we missed plenty.
Joe
Current thread:
- Re: a radical proposal (Re: protocols that don't meet the need...), (continued)
- Re: a radical proposal (Re: protocols that don't meet the need...) David Meyer (Feb 16)
- Re: a radical proposal (Re: protocols that don't meet the need...) william(at)elan.net (Feb 16)
- Re: a radical proposal (Re: protocols that don't meet the need...) James R. Cutler (Feb 16)
- Re: a radical proposal (Re: protocols that don't meet the need...) David Meyer (Feb 16)
- Re: a radical proposal (Re: protocols that don't meet the need...) Iljitsch van Beijnum (Feb 23)
- RE: a radical proposal (Re: protocols that don't meet the need...) Matthew Kaufman (Feb 15)
- RE: a radical proposal (Re: protocols that don't meet the need...) Edward B. DREGER (Feb 15)
- RE: a radical proposal (Re: protocols that don't meet the need...) Matthew Kaufman (Feb 15)
- Re: a radical proposal (Re: protocols that don't meet the need...) Joe Abley (Feb 16)
- Re: a radical proposal (Re: protocols that don't meet the need...) Edward B. DREGER (Feb 16)
- Re: a radical proposal (Re: protocols that don't meet the need...) Joe Abley (Feb 16)
- Re: protocols that don't meet the need... Per Heldal (Feb 15)
- Re: protocols that don't meet the need... Alexei Roudnev (Feb 16)
- Re: protocols that don't meet the need... Mikael Abrahamsson (Feb 16)
- Re: protocols that don't meet the need... Andre Oppermann (Feb 16)
- Re: protocols that don't meet the need... David Meyer (Feb 15)
- Re: protocols that don't meet the need... Mikael Abrahamsson (Feb 15)