nanog mailing list archives
Re: Triple Play [was: CAUTION: Potentially Dumb Question...]
From: Christian Kuhtz <kuhtzch () corp earthlink net>
Date: Mon, 6 Feb 2006 23:39:47 -0500
On Feb 6, 2006, at 11:17 PM, Sean Donelan wrote:
On Mon, 6 Feb 2006, Bora Akyol wrote:He hasn't taken broadcast TV delivery into account in the Triple Play scenario. You gotta plumb them packets good for that...I don't watch anything live anymore, all via Tivo. If Tivo could do bittorrent and download the content, then would I need broadcast?Broadcast remains an extremely efficient method for bulk distribution ofcontent to those TiVo's even if you watch everything on a delay. Somegrad student can probably write a thesis what the cross-over point is for different use conditions. FedEx vs. P2P vs. Unicast vs. Broadcast vs. ???
If you're near real time, you have lots of options actually. And I would contend that p2p can be efficient for broadcast distribution actually. There already are several startups doing exactly that for large scalability.
I think BitTorrent is successfull because that's where the content people want is. I don't think users actually care much about the protocols. We've seen how fickle users can be, quickly migrating to different protocols/applications depending on where the content they want is. Are there any Gopher servers left?
No actual end user (other than the geek crowd) will ever care that it's BitTorrent or whatever. Agreed. But that doesn't mean a bastardization of the idea won't run underneath.
Best regards, Christian
Current thread:
- Triple Play [was: CAUTION: Potentially Dumb Question...] Scott Weeks (Feb 06)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- RE: Triple Play [was: CAUTION: Potentially Dumb Question...] Bora Akyol (Feb 06)
- Re: Triple Play [was: CAUTION: Potentially Dumb Question...] Christian Kuhtz (Feb 06)
- RE: Triple Play [was: CAUTION: Potentially Dumb Question...] Sean Donelan (Feb 06)
- Re: Triple Play [was: CAUTION: Potentially Dumb Question...] Christian Kuhtz (Feb 06)
- Re: Triple Play [was: CAUTION: Potentially Dumb Question...] Sean Donelan (Feb 07)
- Re: Triple Play [was: CAUTION: Potentially Dumb Question...] Christian Kuhtz (Feb 07)