nanog mailing list archives
Re: Issue AS and Subnet Announcment on BGP - Conflict with a major TelCO - 30h+ of route flapping unresolved
From: Alain Hebert <ahebert () pubnix net>
Date: Wed, 16 Nov 2005 00:15:33 -0500
Thanks. ( There is more interesting details but I will reserve myself. (; )We're already working on making contact with the upstreams, but you're right I forgot about making more specific announcement.
Thanks again. Charles Gucker wrote:
On Tue, Nov 15, 2005 at 11:46:35PM -0500, Alain Hebert wrote:Hi,I know somebody that is experiencing route flapping for more than a day now and we found out 10h ago that it was due to the announcement of his subnet by a major TelCO.Once that telco contacted, we got the run around for 10h now and no willingness from their part to fix the problem immediately.Well, a 'normal' solution (short term) would be to announce more specific announcements of your address space, then contact said Telco'supstream providers to have your prefix filtered from their connection(s). A nicely worded (polite) email/fax would go a long way with the NOC. This is of course, if they are not returning your calls, or as you say giving you the run around. I would also try to find a sympathetic body at the telco to help to properly resolve the issue, so you can go back to announcing only your aggregate netblock.We're wondering what is the proper process to make the TelCo correct their behavior and cooperate? (ARIN Conflict Resolution Process, etc ... We found nothing about this situation)ARIN will not step in here. They allocate resources, they do not police or enforce those resources. charles
--Alain Hebert ahebert () pubnix net PubNIX Inc. P.O. Box 175 Beaconsfield, Quebec H9W 5T7
tel 514-990-5911 http://www.pubnix.net fax 514-990-9443
Current thread:
- Issue AS and Subnet Announcment on BGP - Conflict with a major TelCO - 30h+ of route flapping unresolved Alain Hebert (Nov 15)
- Re: Issue AS and Subnet Announcment on BGP - Conflict with a major TelCO - 30h+ of route flapping unresolved Charles Gucker (Nov 15)
- Re: Issue AS and Subnet Announcment on BGP - Conflict with a major TelCO - 30h+ of route flapping unresolved Alain Hebert (Nov 15)
- Re: Issue AS and Subnet Announcment on BGP - Conflict with a major TelCO - 30h+ of route flapping unresolved Blaine Christian (Nov 16)
- Re: Issue AS and Subnet Announcment on BGP - Conflict with a major TelCO - 30h+ of route flapping unresolved Alain Hebert (Nov 16)
- Re: Issue AS and Subnet Announcment on BGP - Conflict with a major TelCo - RESOLVED Alain Hebert (Nov 16)
- Re: Issue AS and Subnet Announcment on BGP - Conflict with a major TelCO - 30h+ of route flapping unresolved Alain Hebert (Nov 15)
- Re: Issue AS and Subnet Announcment on BGP - Conflict with a major TelCO - 30h+ of route flapping unresolved Charles Gucker (Nov 15)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- RE: Issue AS and Subnet Announcment on BGP - Conflict with a major TelCO - 30h+ of route flapping unresolved Bora Akyol (Nov 16)
- Message not available
- RE: Issue AS and Subnet Announcment on BGP - Conflict with a major TelCO - 30h+ of route flapping unresolved Geoff Huston (Nov 17)
- Re: Issue AS and Subnet Announcment on BGP - Conflict with a major TelCO - 30h+ of route flapping unresolved Jeroen Massar (Nov 17)
- Re: Issue AS and Subnet Announcment on BGP - Conflict with a major TelCO - 30h+ of route flapping unresolved Geoff Huston (Nov 17)
- Message not available