nanog mailing list archives
Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill
From: Scott Call <scall () devolution com>
Date: Wed, 23 Mar 2005 10:29:20 -0800 (PST)
On Wed, 23 Mar 2005 Michael.Dillon () radianz com wrote:
that's EASY: there is hyperconcern for the welfare of children in Utah,Finally, someone who recognizes what this bill is all about. It merely asks ISPs to provide parents with a filtering tool that cannot be overridden by their children because the process of filtering takes place entirely outside the home.
To Quote Peter Tolan (Cowriter of the TV Show "Rescue me") on another censorship issue: "The idea that government feels they have to regulate this stuff because the people they're governing can't turn it off is insulting"
Why is it the ISP's responsibility to assume an operational burden of enforcing the religious morality of one group? I think the phrase "Chilling effect" has been used in this thread previously, and I believe it was apt.
If there's a demand to an alternative internet service by, for example, Mormons, why not start an ISP with filtering, and offer it? Niche businesses service narrow segments of the market have been very successful, even if they charge slightly more, based on their specialized appeal.
If aol/comcast/rboc/etc see that they are loosing customers to competition, they may choose to offer similar services or choose to let the customers go.
Current thread:
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill, (continued)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Bill Woodcock (Mar 22)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Rachael Treu (Mar 22)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Steve Gibbard (Mar 22)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Paul G (Mar 22)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Rachael Treu (Mar 22)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill David Barak (Mar 22)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Michael . Dillon (Mar 23)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Geo. (Mar 23)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Eric Brunner-Williams in Portland Maine (Mar 23)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Steven J. Sobol (Mar 23)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Scott Call (Mar 23)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Barry Shein (Mar 23)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill pashdown (Mar 22)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Richard Irving (Mar 22)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Randy Bush (Mar 22)
- the gateway of delight (was Net-porn bill) Lucy E. Lynch (Mar 22)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Rich Kulawiec (Mar 23)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Petri Helenius (Mar 23)
- Message not available
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Jay R. Ashworth (Mar 23)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Owen DeLong (Mar 22)
- Re: Utah governor signs Net-porn bill Steven J. Sobol (Mar 22)