nanog mailing list archives
Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls
From: "Eric A. Hall" <ehall () ehsco com>
Date: Thu, 18 Aug 2005 03:07:57 -0400
On 8/18/2005 2:59 AM, Richard A Steenbergen wrote:
On Thu, Aug 18, 2005 at 02:44:59AM -0400, Eric A. Hall wrote:On 8/17/2005 10:04 PM, Fergie (Paul Ferguson) wrote:A new law that's apparently the first in the nation threatens to penalize Internet service providers that fail to warn users that some dial-up numbers can ring up enormous long-distance phone bills even though they appear local.aka, make ISPs liable for other people's fraud. What's the thinking here, anybody know?Erm... Requiring that ISPs notify customers that phone numbers in the same area code may not be "local" has WHAT exactly to do with making ISPs liable for other people's fraud?
If there's a penalty for failing to ~adequately track and notify customers then that's a liability, by definition. Seems to me the appropriate response is for the AG office to pursue the people who are running the toll scams, not to push enforcement out to uninvolved third parties. Having dealt with AGs in the past, I know that's just whistling dixie, but still the notion of introducing liability is kind of spooky. -- Eric A. Hall http://www.ehsco.com/ Internet Core Protocols http://www.oreilly.com/catalog/coreprot/
Current thread:
- New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Fergie (Paul Ferguson) (Aug 17)
- Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Eric A. Hall (Aug 17)
- Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Richard A Steenbergen (Aug 17)
- Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Eric A. Hall (Aug 18)
- Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Greg Boehnlein (Aug 18)
- Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Richard A Steenbergen (Aug 17)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Richard A Steenbergen (Aug 18)
- Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Sean Donelan (Aug 18)
- Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Richard A Steenbergen (Aug 18)
- Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Jonathan M. Slivko (Aug 18)
- Apologies for Triple Post - Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Jonathan M. Slivko (Aug 18)
- Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Sean Donelan (Aug 18)
- Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Jonathan M. Slivko (Aug 18)
- Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Sean Donelan (Aug 18)
- Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Jonathan M. Slivko (Aug 18)
- Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Jonathan M. Slivko (Aug 18)
- Re: New N.Y. Law Targets Hidden Net LD Tolls Eric A. Hall (Aug 17)