nanog mailing list archives
Re: Anti-spam System Idea
From: "Christopher L. Morrow" <chris () UU NET>
Date: Mon, 16 Feb 2004 01:59:51 +0000 (GMT)
On Sun, 15 Feb 2004, Jon R. Kibler wrote:
To me, the approach you advocate is something like saying "do away with any centralized law enforcement, force everyone to carry guns, and if anyone suspects that someone else is committing a crime, they are obliged to shoot them." I believe that blocking
So, what Sean is proposing, and what you accurately describe (mostly) here is how the Internet is intended to be run... Minus the 'and the people running the systems should be "smart" or "careful" or "considerate"' of course. There was never any central control/enforcement for the Internet, and time and again Governments have been shown that its next to impossible to BE that central enforcer... With the exception, possibly, of China though one could successfully argue that their firewall isn't working so well if hundreds of thousands of hosts on their networks can get compromised and flood out spoofed ip datagrams, eh?
Current thread:
- Re: Anti-spam System Idea, (continued)
- Re: Anti-spam System Idea Valdis . Kletnieks (Feb 15)
- Re: Anti-spam System Idea jlewis (Feb 15)
- Re: Anti-spam System Idea Jon R. Kibler (Feb 15)
- Re: Anti-spam System Idea Daniel Reed (Feb 16)
- Re: Anti-spam System Idea Sean Donelan (Feb 15)
- Re: Anti-spam System Idea Valdis . Kletnieks (Feb 15)
- Identifying IP address types Sean Donelan (Feb 15)
- Re: Anti-spam System Idea Jon R. Kibler (Feb 15)
- Re: Anti-spam System Idea Sean Donelan (Feb 15)
- Re: Anti-spam System Idea Jon R. Kibler (Feb 15)
- Re: Anti-spam System Idea Christopher L. Morrow (Feb 15)
- Re: Anti-spam System Idea Jon R. Kibler (Feb 16)
- Re: Anti-spam System Idea Christopher L. Morrow (Feb 16)
- Re: Anti-spam System Idea J Bacher (Feb 16)
- RE: Anti-spam System Idea Timothy R. McKee (Feb 16)
- Re: Anti-spam System Idea Petri Helenius (Feb 16)
- RE: Anti-spam System Idea Timothy R. McKee (Feb 16)
- RE: Anti-spam System Idea Scott McGrath (Feb 17)
- Clueless service restrictions (was RE: Anti-spam System Idea) Tony Hain (Feb 17)
- Re: Clueless service restrictions (was RE: Anti-spam System Idea) Steven M. Bellovin (Feb 17)
- Re: Clueless service restrictions (was RE: Anti-spam System Idea) Jun-ichiro itojun Hagino (Feb 17)