nanog mailing list archives

Re: An A record is an MX record and is a missing MX....


From: Richard Irving <rirving () onecall net>
Date: Thu, 03 Apr 2003 17:25:35 -0500


Gerardo Gregory wrote:
<snip>
Since then I have learned that some MTA's will look for an A record if it
cannot find an MX record and use the A record instead.

  Once upon a time that was near all Micr0$loth did...

Is this acceptable (in a "best case scenario") as a correct method?

  It isn't exactly completely RFC compliant, but, it is only a -=Request=-, eh ?

   But, FWIW, since when is a system =-without-= proper fall backs, 
  a "best case scenario" ?

Obviously some admins I have encountered are starting to host mailservers
for sub-domains and domains without MX entries on their DNS zone records.
Relying on the A record alone.

   Lemmings make a mad dash towards a cliff, every so often, en masse....

  * shrug *

  Go figure.  :P

Gerardo A. Gregory

  :)


Current thread: