nanog mailing list archives
Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed
From: JC Dill <nanog () vo cnchost com>
Date: Sat, 26 Oct 2002 10:33:22 -0700
On 05:16 AM 10/24/02, Etaoin Shrdlu wrote: > >Alan Hannan wrote: >>>> > I don't understand how giving the US federal government management control
>> > of key components of the Internet will make it more secure. >> >> It worked for airline security. > >Sure, searching Ray Charles makes me feel much safer. Asking me whether any >one helped me packed my bags or handed me a package always shows whether or >not I should be trusted to get on the plane. Stopping a little boy from >taking on a toy with a 1 inch long gun makes me feel safer too. These are >the same people who can't be trusted to make sure that your luggage flies >the same flight you do. Puh-leeze. > >There is not one single thing that goes on in airport "security" that >contributes one whit to actual security.Amazingly enough, Admiral James M. Loy - the new COO of the Transportation Security Administration, shows strong signs of having a clue WRT security, see:
<http://www.cnn.com/2002/US/08/23/loy.cnna/>In an opinion piece by Joseph Perkins (San Diego Union-Tribune columnist, the article ran in the SF Chronicle on 10/21 but I can't find it online anywhere), it lists a bunch of the present stupid rules, and then goes on to say:
So those dictates and others like them, included on Loys' not-so- facetiously named "Stupid Rule List," have been thrown out. The litmus test in each case, he explained, is whether a rule substantively contributes to security or primarily to longer airport lines. There are several online references to this list, see: <http://www.apfa.org/public/articles/News-Events/STUPID_RULES.HTML> <http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A32246-2002Oct15.html>ObNetwork Operations: Does this mean I can once again carry a cable crimper tool with me in my carry on luggage (one was confiscated at SFO a few months ago, the cable cutting blades were deemed a "potential weapon")?
jc
Current thread:
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed, (continued)
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed Richard Forno (Oct 23)
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed Christopher L. Morrow (Oct 23)
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed David Conrad (Oct 24)
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed David Conrad (Oct 24)
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed David Conrad (Oct 24)
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed Alan Hannan (Oct 23)
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed Daniel Karrenberg (Oct 23)
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed Vadim Antonov (Oct 24)
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed Etaoin Shrdlu (Oct 24)
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed Chrisy Luke (Oct 24)
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed Mathew Lodge (Oct 25)
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed JC Dill (Oct 26)
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed Jeff Shultz (Oct 24)
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed Chris Adams (Oct 24)
- Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed sgorman1 (Oct 24)