Releasing AS numbers for misconfigured nets

[Avleen Vig <lists-nanog () silverwraith com>]

I hope I don't spark off a huge discussion on this :-)
But having said that, I am looking for personal as well as professional
opinions.

This email is being posted to both RIPE-EOF and NANOG as the decision
could be helpful to both parties, not just those in the RIPE region.

Background:
A many weeks ago, SAFE (http://www.ircnetops.org/smurf) to the decision
not to release the IP addresses of smurf amplifiers, only the weekly
statistics on smurf amplifiers in RIPE IP space as a whole. This was to
partly protect the misconfigured networks from being abused at a time when
they may not be able to fix the problem immediately.

Now:
A number of requests have been made for SAFE to release the AS number of
unco-operative[1] large (x500+ reply) smurf amplifiers, so that ISP's can
filter these people out more easily.

Further requests have been made that the AS numbers for *all* large smurf
amplifiers be released weekly.

What are the different thoughts people have on this?


Kindest regards,


[1] = those who fail to close an open smurf amplifier by the third check.
Checks are performed weekly. Notifications are emails to 'abuse', 'tech-c'
and 'admin-c' contacts as listed in the RIPE WHOIS database.

-- 
Avleen Vig
Network Security Officer
Smurf Amplifier Finding Executive: http://www.ircnetops.org/smurf