nanog mailing list archives
Re: Communities
From: alex () yuriev com
Date: Tue, 16 Oct 2001 13:00:45 -0400 (EDT)
This seems to need quite some engineering work. :-)I've thought about this before. Let's say that I have a DS3 to 701 and a 4xDS1 to 7018. I might sell a DS1 to NetX, and advert their routes[1] to both upstreams. If I sell a 15Mbps frac-DS3 to NetZ, I'd better use my 7018 connection for backup only on their routes.
Router (A) policy 701 Router (B) policy 7018 Router (C) your policy ( 701 && 7018 && whatever else you have) Where is the problem again? We, Netaxs, (AS4969) do this in multiple locations with multiple OC-12s to different transit providers and our own network where some customers want to always use a specific path or not use any path at all, while the others do not want to be bothered about which path can be used. That is all done today with Cisco and Juniper gear and confederations, without need for any random changes to BGP protocol.
On a side note, A's possibilities of influencing inbound routing decisions - given that B acts on communities set by A, like `Prepend own ASN a few times before sending over just this link' or `Don't announce to D at all' - are already technically possible. Frankly, if I were BCorrect. And a few upstreams allow this.
It is very simple to do. Create a set of 'advertise-me' communities and 'pad-me' communities. Alex
Current thread:
- Re: Communities, (continued)
- Re: Communities Niels Bakker (Oct 16)
- Re: Communities Iljitsch van Beijnum (Oct 16)
- Re: Communities E.B. Dreger (Oct 16)
- Re: Communities Niels Bakker (Oct 16)
- Re: Communities E.B. Dreger (Oct 16)
- Re: Communities Niels Bakker (Oct 17)
- Re: Communities Greg Maxwell (Oct 17)
- Re: Communities Hank Nussbacher (Oct 17)
- Re: Communities Iljitsch van Beijnum (Oct 18)
- Re: Communities Hank Nussbacher (Oct 18)
- Re: Communities alex (Oct 16)
- Re: Communities Jeffrey Haas (Oct 18)
- Re: Communities Geoff Huston (Oct 18)
- Re: Communities E.B. Dreger (Oct 15)
- Re: Communities Jeff Aitken (Oct 15)
- Re: Communities Iljitsch van Beijnum (Oct 16)
- RE: Communities E.B. Dreger (Oct 16)
- Re: Communities Niels Bakker (Oct 16)