nanog mailing list archives
Re: EMAIL != FTP
From: Mitch Halmu <mitch () netside net>
Date: Sat, 26 May 2001 19:23:16 -0400 (EDT)
On Sat, 26 May 2001, John Fraizer wrote:
On Sat, 26 May 2001, Mitch Halmu wrote:On Sat, 26 May 2001, Adam Rothschild wrote:If you don't want to get listed in the ORBS, don't run an open relay, or prevent them from scanning you. If this is too difficult too implement, or the negative impact on your business resulting from commonly-accepted responsible operational practices is too severe, then you can deal with the consequences of being blackholed by ORBS subscribers. Your choice. -adamAny North American Network Operator (NANO_) that entrusts control of their networks' communications to a foreign third party is a fool. ORBS is run by one Alan Brown based in New Zealand. IMHO, he's a cyberterrorist. Being blackholed by New Zealanders should be an insignificant threat to US-based networks. If it starts being a noticeable problem, you have a serious national security breach. --Mitch NetSideMitch, I'm not a huge fan of ORBS. We don't use it. This is based on the fact that we don't like their tactics. I do make use of MAPS however. That said, the fact that someone is using either service and perhaps your email doesn't go through has absolutely NOTHING to do with national security. It has everything to do with YOUR security. If your MTA is closed to SPAM problems and you and your customers don't SPAM, you have no problems. If you refuse to secure your MTA, that's YOUR problem and many of us have taken steps to prevent YOUR problem from becoming OUR problem. --- John Fraizer EnterZone, Inc
Did I happen to mention MAPS in my post? I didn't. The argument was made for ORBS, or any FOREIGN entity that blocks North American networks. ORBS fans in this country will have lots of explaining to do and hell to pay if any foreign entity exploits this weakness to attack US interests in an international incident. Our position on MAPS is described clearly at http://www.dotcomeon.com I don't want to start a debate on MAPS and be accused of OT trolling. --Mitch NetSide
Current thread:
- RE: EMAIL != FTP, (continued)
- RE: EMAIL != FTP Rowland, Alan D (May 25)
- RE: EMAIL != FTP Roeland Meyer (May 25)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP Richard A. Steenbergen (May 25)
- RE: EMAIL != FTP Roeland Meyer (May 26)
- RE: EMAIL != FTP Stephen J. Wilcox (May 26)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP Wojtek Zlobicki (May 26)
- RE: EMAIL != FTP Roeland Meyer (May 26)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP Adam Rothschild (May 26)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP Mitch Halmu (May 26)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP John Fraizer (May 26)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP Mitch Halmu (May 26)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP Valdis . Kletnieks (May 26)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP Mitch Halmu (May 27)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP Jim Mercer (May 27)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP Steve Sobol (May 28)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP Adam Rothschild (May 26)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP Scott Francis (May 27)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP Jim Mercer (May 26)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP Sabri Berisha (May 28)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP Stephen J. Wilcox (May 26)