RE: Multiple Roots are "a good thing" - Karl Auerbach

[Roeland Meyer <rmeyer () mhsc com>]

> From: woods () weird com [mailto:woods () weird com]
> Sent: Sunday, March 18, 2001 12:01 PM

> The correct way to fight against a DNS root controlled by someone you
> don't like is not to propose multiple DNS roots, but rather 
> to campaign for a democratic root.  

That campaign has been on-going for quite a few years. It continues to go
nowhere. The rest of us are begining to get fed-up with the anti-progress.
Kent Crispin repeatedly claims that ICANN is a corporation and not a
democratic entity. In this case he is correct. I disagree with him that this
is a desired outcome. Crispin and Crocker are of the opinion that
(non-democratic) status quo is acceptable.

> Auerbach's proposal is not 
> technically sound and
> is political suicide.

As someone who spoke with Karl before he wrote that proposal, there was a
lot involved that wasn't published.