nanog mailing list archives
Re: new.net
From: "David Schwartz" <davids () webmaster com>
Date: Fri, 9 Mar 2001 13:32:53 -0800
How do you propose to enforce this? What authority will be able to intercede in a trademark lawsuit involving a domain outside .tm, and put a stop to it? The namespace is the namespace, and infringment is infringment, whereever
it
occurs. If infringment occurs, the damaged party should not be prevented from seeking relief.
The problem is not infringement. Obviously, if there's actual trademark infringement, it should be dealt with no matter what domain it occurs in. The problem is the exceptional protections that go way beyond traditional infringement/dilution/deception/confusion that are being granted to domain names in some TLDs. If you look at most domain disputes that have resulted in a domain being transferred, you will not see any actual confusion, deception, trademark dilution, or actual trademark infringement. What you will see is exceptional protection that goes way beyond what any court of law would give to an actual trademark. One can argue that these exceptional protections are justified because of the special nature of some TLDs. So the logical thing to do, if you don't like the exceptional protections, is to change the nature of the TLDs. That is why suggestions to change the meaning of .com or add new trademark-oriented TLDs _are_ on target. DS
Current thread:
- Re: new.net, (continued)
- Re: new.net richb (Mar 08)
- Re: new.net Jim Dixon (Mar 08)
- Re: new.net richb (Mar 08)
- Re: new.net Simon Lockhart (Mar 08)
- Re: new.net Scott Gifford (Mar 09)
- RE: new.net Mike Batchelor (Mar 09)
- RE: new.net Charles Scott (Mar 09)
- RE: new.net Mike Batchelor (Mar 09)
- Re: new.net Scott Gifford (Mar 09)
- Re: new.net Charles Scott (Mar 10)
- RE: new.net Mike Batchelor (Mar 09)
- Re: new.net Scott Gifford (Mar 09)
- Re: new.net David Schwartz (Mar 09)
- Re: new.net Josh Richards (Mar 10)
- Re: new.net Martin Hannigan (Mar 08)
- RE: new.net Ken Eddings (Mar 08)
- Re: new.net Shawn McMahon (Mar 09)
- RE: new.net Ian Cooper (Mar 09)