nanog mailing list archives

Re: What does 95th %tile mean?


From: Toby_Williams () enron net
Date: Fri, 20 Apr 2001 10:19:17 +0100




_95th%ile is not a robust mechanism for billing_
 It neither addresses variance nor average use effectively and can be gamed
quite easily. It's some kind of best fit system for billing buyers with "normal
behaviour".

Where in maths class did they ever say that scraping off the highest n percent
of a data set in isolation, gives a good indication of anything? Don't you need
to look at the mean and 90th percentile together to fairly evaulate
distribution.

I think the reason it's so popular currently is that it's easy to describe
(hence sell) and fits normal use reasonably well, so from a "normal buyer's"
perspective is OK. Just as long as everyone is honest.

In a thirty day billing period 95th%ile gives you one and a half days of  *free
bandwidth*. 90th%ile gives you three days of *free bandwidth*.


Current thread: