nanog mailing list archives
Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20
From: Greg Maxwell <gmaxwell () martin fl us>
Date: Tue, 10 Apr 2001 08:27:54 -0400 (EDT)
On Mon, 9 Apr 2001, Eric A. Hall wrote:
Actually, the last I heard is that they will sell down to a /24.No. See http://www.arin.net/regserv/feeschedule.html "The minimum block of IP address space assigned by ARIN is a /20." Also, they don't have any special-case handling that I am aware of. I tried to get a private /24 to use for the topology examples in my books and couldn't get one. ARIN outright refused the request even though I could prove the need for it, and even though I didn't care about global routing or reachability. I was also told that any /24 that I might manage to acquire would be revoked instead of transferred to me. I honestly believe that ARIN is funded by stock ownership in NAT provder technologies. They are the primary reason that we have NAT and RFC 1918 problems on the net everyday.
No, thats really not fair. I'm probably more of a NAT hater then most people here, but I can't agree with that. The reason they don't allocate /24's is because without aggregation the Internet is not scalable. Perhaps they are being too agressive, but the reasoning is sound.
Current thread:
- RE: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20, (continued)
- RE: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 mike harrison (Apr 09)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Eric A. Hall (Apr 09)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Andy Dills (Apr 09)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Eric Gauthier (Apr 09)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Eric A. Hall (Apr 09)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 bmanning (Apr 09)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Eric A. Hall (Apr 09)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Eric A. Hall (Apr 09)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Stephen Griffin (Apr 09)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Majdi S. Abbas (Apr 09)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Greg Maxwell (Apr 10)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Adrian Chadd (Apr 10)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Greg Maxwell (Apr 10)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Majdi S. Abbas (Apr 10)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Patrick Evans (Apr 10)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 John Fraizer (Apr 10)
- Message not available
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Majdi S. Abbas (Apr 10)
- Message not available
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Majdi S. Abbas (Apr 10)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 James Thomason (Apr 10)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Greg Maxwell (Apr 10)
- Re: Getting a "portable" /19 or /20 Christopher A. Woodfield (Apr 10)