nanog mailing list archives
Re: AS_PATH length and route selection (WAS: Strange BGP announcement)
From: Ben Black <black () layer8 net>
Date: Wed, 18 Nov 1998 10:39:45 -0800
The key to this is that the administrative preference in question has domain scope. Assuming you are correctly implementing iBGP, whether with a full mesh, reflectors, or confederations, and assuming consistent announcements from external route originators, then you can't make a loop because the same policy is in effect for all the routers in the AS. Incomplete iBGP implementations and router-local administrative preferences can easily be used to create loops, but that is certainly not a problem with BGP. Ben On Tue, Nov 17, 1998 at 05:49:21PM -0800, Tony Li wrote:
| This, of course, leads to many, many other questions (such as the | possibility routing loops caused by different local policies as was seen | with implementations of BGP4), but few of which are of a truly operational | issue. So I will apologize for starting a thread based on mis-information | and go back to my cave. Different local policies should all be reflected in the LOCAL_PREF, which should be distributed to all nodes within the domain. This should lead to consistent decisions within the domain and thus should avoid stable forwarding loops. Tony
Current thread:
- Re: Strange BGP announcement Enke Chen (Nov 10)
- RE: Strange BGP announcement Winfried Haug (Nov 13)
- Re: Strange BGP announcement Enke Chen (Nov 13)
- Re: Strange BGP announcement Andrew Bangs (Nov 13)
- Re: Strange BGP announcement I Am Not An Isp (Nov 16)
- Re: Strange BGP announcement Andrew Bangs (Nov 17)
- Re: Strange BGP announcement I Am Not An Isp (Nov 17)
- Re: Strange BGP announcement Tony Li (Nov 17)
- AS_PATH length and route selection (WAS: Strange BGP announcement) I Am Not An Isp (Nov 17)
- Re: AS_PATH length and route selection (WAS: Strange BGP announcement) Tony Li (Nov 17)
- Re: AS_PATH length and route selection (WAS: Strange BGP announcement) Ben Black (Nov 18)
- Re: Strange BGP announcement Enke Chen (Nov 13)
- RE: Strange BGP announcement Winfried Haug (Nov 13)
- Re: Strange BGP announcement Vijay Gill (Nov 17)
- Message not available
- AS_PATH length and route selection (WAS: Strange BGP announcement) I Am Not An Isp (Nov 17)
- Re: AS_PATH length and route selection (WAS: Strange BGP announcement) Vijay Gill (Nov 17)
- Re: AS_PATH length and route selection (WAS: Strange BGP announcement) Sean M. Doran (Nov 20)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- RE: Strange BGP announcement Martin, Christian (Nov 17)