nanog mailing list archives
Re: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape
From: hostmaster () starfire douglas ma us (Ron Kimball)
Date: Fri, 30 May 1997 01:14:18 GMT
On Thu, 29 May 1997 20:01:29 -0500, Karl wrote:
On Fri, May 30, 1997 at 12:48:23AM +0000, Ron Kimball wrote:On Thu, 29 May 1997 19:14:29 -0500, Jim wrote:Karl, I am not sure that uDNS claims to be "better" than eDNS.If by "eDNS" you mean Karl's thing, yes we do claim to be better in the areas that count. We will never dump the entire root zone to a "clean slate" and tell people this is a "good thing". We will supply stable, business grade service with no "Freezes", "Ultimatums", or "Premaddona posturing"... Take care, RonYep, stable, business-grade service. On recursion-enabled servers. Yep. BTW, the reason the original system is being re-qualified (which is what it is) is that a bunch of people were cheating. You mean you, and the others, can't qualify under the rules of *stable, business grade service*, defined as: 1) Someone answers your phone. 2) You are actually registered to legally do business in your state. 3) You have real nameservers on real circuits. 4) Someone can actually register electronically in your TLD. 5) Someone can use the web and/or whois to look up who owns a SLD delegation. Well, blow me down. Must be some fancy new definition of "stable, business grade service" here if you folks don't meet these criteria. Oh, and we're not assessing taxes. Still. Ron, all you have to do is file the template. I know that's tough, but the truth of the matter is that 90% of the TLDs which your defectors are now putting up under "uDNS" don't meet the above *FOUR* criteria, say much less being non-collusive and holding 10 or fewer TLDs.
<yawn> - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Current thread:
- RE: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape - on a couple ISDN lines Jim Fleming (May 29)
- Re: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape - on a couple ISDN lines Karl Denninger (May 29)
- Re: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape Ron Kimball (May 29)
- Re: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape Karl Denninger (May 29)
- Re: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape Ron Kimball (May 29)
- Re: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape John Charles Broomfield (May 29)
- Re: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape Karl Denninger (May 29)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- RE: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape - on a couple ISDN lines Jim Fleming (May 29)
- RE: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape - on a couple ISDN lines Ben Black (May 29)
- Re: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape - on a couple T100 lines Ron Kimball (May 29)
- RE: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape - on a couple ISDN lines Jim Fleming (May 29)
- RE: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape - on a couple ISDN lines Ben Black (May 29)
- RE: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape - on a couple ISDN lines Jim Fleming (May 29)
- RE: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape - on a couple ISDN lines Timothy C. Brown (May 29)
- RE: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape - on a couple ISDN lines Jim Fleming (May 29)
- RE: uDNS Root Name Servers Taking Shape - on a couple ISDN lines Jim Fleming (May 29)
(Thread continues...)