nanog mailing list archives
Re: Customer AS
From: Avi Freedman <freedman () netaxs com>
Date: Sat, 17 Aug 1996 16:47:30 -0400 (EDT)
This is mainly due to the fact that Sprint does not listen to any announcements from its peers for anything within its "non-portable" blocks.What?!? I.e. if a Sprint customer C is multi-homed and their Sprint line goes down, traffic to C from other Sprint customers will not be able to reach C?
Yes. Sean encourage(s/ed) other providers to do the same sort of filtering. He doesn't like the fact that he's still carrying stuff inside his network that he would filter from a peer, but apparently he's hoping that someone else (some other provider) will force the issue for him (inside of Sprintlink).
BTW, Sprint also does not listen to any of its peers ASes through other peers so peering with Sprint and still paying someone for transit services do not help you get more redundancy with Sprint's network.And this is considered good networking architecture? Jeezus!
It's a reasonable way to make sure that your peers won't f*ck you by redistributing routes for everyone else into you through their session. If that's your goal, you either have to limit the as-paths you'll hear from a peer or not hear routes with any peer's AS through any other peer. And it has the side-benefit of making people realize that they'd better run a *real* network with good connectivity between their interior and all of the exchange points they're at. (Meaning if you peer with someone with this policy, you're on your own as far as connectivity to that someone).
randy
Avi - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Current thread:
- Re: Customer AS, (continued)
- Re: Customer AS Paul A Vixie (Aug 21)
- Re: Customer AS Sean Doran (Aug 17)
- Re: Customer AS Henry Kilmer (Aug 21)
- Re: Customer AS Jon Zeeff (Aug 21)
- Re: Customer AS Michael Dillon (Aug 21)
- Re: Customer AS Avi Freedman (Aug 21)
- Re: Customer AS Curtis Villamizar (Aug 21)
- Re: Customer AS Sean Doran (Aug 21)
- Re: Customer AS Henry Kilmer (Aug 17)
- Re: Customer AS Randy Bush (Aug 17)
- Re: Customer AS Avi Freedman (Aug 17)
- Re: Customer AS Sean Doran (Aug 17)
- Re: Customer AS Curtis Villamizar (Aug 21)
- Re: Customer AS Alex.Bligh (Aug 21)
- Re: Customer AS Curtis Villamizar (Aug 21)
- Re: Customer AS Alex.Bligh (Aug 21)
- Re: Customer AS Avi Freedman (Aug 21)