nanog mailing list archives
Re: US Domain -- County Delegations
From: nordlund () databank com
Date: Thu, 27 Jul 95 11:51:55 cdt
It appears to me that we are making some rather weird assumptions here, based on history in other environments (like current domain names, phone numbers, USMail addresses, and so). It is not so clear to me that there will always be a one-to-one mapping between the destination one wants to reach, and some name like vixie.sf.ca.us. Eventually such strict bindings will hurt us even more than they do today. What do you really want? Well, I want to email Joe Smith? No way, there are too many of those, give me more information? So, eventually may be we have to deal with more levels of indirection and some data base support that allows us to zoom in, and, like it or not, perhaps introduce some margin of error ("sorry, wrong number, find another Vixie")
Hmmm. Like X.400/500?? state=XX, country=US, surname=Jones, Givenname=Pete city=YY, neighborhood=sunnyside, street=rockfence etc. etc.
I think in our discussions we have ways too much a historical Internet perspective with strict bindings in mind, and names and addresses that are supposed to last for lfetimes. This will not work. Ther are too many people, too many companies, too many mapping strategies out there. Whether I email to "Vixie, the bind dude," or "Vixie, the networking person living in Northern California," may be there should be algorithms and facilities in place that map those to the same person. Perhaps even in ways the information (such as email) follows him, rather than him having to chase after his email (e.g., remap his "current" location when/after he moves). What names or addresses things eventually map to should be fairly irrelevant in terms of perceived complexity, as you'd alias Joe Smith@whereever to some short version in your personal alias/nickname file anyway. Or is that just mapping information for a data base supported translation server?
Dave Nordlund Dir of Technical Svcs Databank, Inc 913/842-6699 1473 Hwy 40 nordlund () databank com Lawrence, KS 66044 "Your Key to the Internet
Current thread:
- Re: US Domain -- County Delegations, (continued)
- Re: US Domain -- County Delegations Curtis Villamizar (Jul 27)
- Re: US Domain -- County Delegations Paul A Vixie (Jul 27)
- Re: US Domain -- County Delegations Kevin Oberman (Jul 27)
- Re: US Domain -- County Delegations Mike Lawrie (Jul 27)
- Re: US Domain -- County Delegations Alan Barrett (Jul 27)
- Re: US Domain -- County Delegations Paul A Vixie (Jul 27)
- Re: US Domain -- County Delegations Michael Dillon (Jul 27)
- Re: US Domain -- County Delegations Geert Jan de Groot (Jul 28)
- Re: US Domain -- County Delegations Curtis Villamizar (Jul 28)
- Re: US Domain -- County Delegations Michael Dillon (Jul 28)
- Re: US Domain -- County Delegations Paul A Vixie (Jul 28)